Dear Visitors - Welcome to Meeting in Music !

All music lovers are cordially invited to participate at our Meeting in Music collective, a central gathering point for bloggers dedicated to sharing music and enhancing the enjoyment of same. MIMIC features pertinent articles, links to the best classical blogs on the web, and occasional links to sample some of the great music discussed amongst MIMIC members.

Please join us to contribute, partake of what is offered and to chat with fellow music-lovers from around the world. Those enrolling as FOLLOWERS of this blog are encouraged to request posting rights to become contributors.

Are you looking for a specific recording that you just can't seem to find anywhere? Maybe one of your fellow members of the this community can help you. Place your request in the chat box but please keep it on a modest and reasonable level and remember that the more you help others, the more they will try to help you.

On behalf of the MIMIC team
Scoredaddy


Most recent comments:
Following the guide below you will be able to create the ultimate HQ rip and upload for sharing here at the Meeting in Music Internet Community or on your own blog if you have one.
RIPPING A CD USING EXACT AUDIO COPY (EAC)
1. Start Exact Audio Copy and load the clean and scratchless CD into you drive.
2. Pressing ALT+G will pull track and album info from the FreeDB database if this feature is set up properly.
3. If no info is found the CD is not registered in the database and you will have to type in the info manually.
4. Adjust the Drive Settings according to the model of your drive and enable the ”Create Log-file” option.
5. Adjust the Compression Settings to rip in Flac format at 768 kBit/s. Alternatively rip in the Ape fomat.
6. Rip the CD by pressing Action -> Test & Copy Image & Create CUE Sheet -> Compressed...
7. Check the log-file to see if any ripping errors or AccurateRip inaccuracies were registered.
SCANNING THE COVERS OF THE ALBUM
1. Scans of the front and back covers should be included if available as should the booklet. 300dpi is standard.
COMPRESSING THE FOLDER USING WINRAR
1. Wrap the audio files and images in a folder marked the composer and album name etc.
2. Set Compression method to ”Store” and the volume size to 200000000. Add a 3% recovery record.
3. Compress the folder using a not-too-obvious filename.
UPLOADING TO A FILEHOST AND SHARING WITH THE WORLD
Now all you need to do is to upload the rar-files to a filehost of your choice. Mega.nz is the standard and most stable option but there are many others and some services even feature upload to multiple filehosts. Finally the download links are ready to be presented on your blog.
THE MEDIEVAL ERA (600 - 1450)

At around 500 AD, western civilization began to emerge from the period known as “The Dark Ages”, the time when invading hordes of Vandals, Huns and Visigoths overran Europe and brought an end to the Roman Empire. For the next ten centuries, the newly emerging Christian Church would dominate Europe, administering justice, instigating “Holy” Crusades against the East, establishing universities, and generally dictating the destiny of music, art and literature

During this time, Pope Gregory I is generally believed to have collected and codified the music known as Gregorian Chant, which was the approved music of the Church. Much later, the University at Notre Dame in Paris saw the creation of a new kind of music called organum.

Secular music was sung all over Europe by the troubadours and trouvères of France, and it was during the Middle Ages that western culture saw the arrival of the first great name in music, Guilliame de Machaut.
THE RENAISSANCE ERA (1450 - 1600)

Generally considered to be from c.1420 to 1600, the Renaissance (which literally means “rebirth”) was a time of great cultural awakening and a flowering of the arts, letters, and sciences throughout Europe.

With the rise of humanism, sacred music began for the first time to break free of the confines of the Church, and a school of composers trained in the Netherlands mastered the art of polyphony in their settings of sacred music. One of the early masters of the Flemish style was Josquin des Prez. These polyphonic traditions reached their culmination in the unsurpassed works of Giovanni da Palestrina.

The late Renaissance also saw in England the flourishing of the English madrigal, the best known of which were composed by such masters as John Dowland, William Byrd, Thomas Morley and others.
THE BAROQUE ERA (1600 - 1750)

Named after the popular ornate architectural style of the time, the Baroque period (c.1600 to 1750) saw composers beginning to rebel against the styles that were prevalent during the High Renaissance. Many monarchs employed composers at their courts, where they were little more than servants expected to churn out music for any desired occasions. The greatest composer of the period, Johann Sebastian Bach, was such a servant. Yet the best composers of the time were able to break new musical ground, and in so doing succeeded in creating an entirely new style of music.

The instrumental concerto became a staple of the Baroque era, and found its strongest exponent in the works of the Venetian composer Antonio Vivaldi. Harpsichord music achieved new heights, due to the works of such masters as Domenico Scarlatti and others. But vocal and choral music still reigned supreme during this age, and culminated in the operas and oratorios of German-born composer George Frideric Handel.
THE CLASSICAL ERA (1750 - 1820)

From roughly 1750 to 1820, artists, architects, and musicians moved away from the heavily ornamented styles of the Baroque and the Rococo, and instead embraced a clean, uncluttered style they thought reminiscent of Classical Greece.

At this time the Austrian capital of Vienna became the musical centre of Europe, and works of the period are often referred to as being in the Viennese style. Composers came from all over Europe to train in and around Vienna, and gradually they developed and formalized the standard musical forms that were to dominate European musical culture for the next several decades. The Classical period reached its majestic culmination with the masterful symphonies, sonatas, and string quartets by the three great composers of the Viennese school: Franz Joseph Haydn, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, and Ludwig van Beethoven.

During the same period, the first voice of the burgeoning Romantic musical ethic can be found in the music of Viennese composer Franz Schubert.
THE ROMANTIC ERA (1820 - 1910)

The earliest Romantic composers were all born within a few years of each other in the early years of the nineteenth century. These include the great German masters Felix Mendelssohn and Robert Schumann; the Polish poet of the piano Frédéric Chopin; the French genius Hector Berlioz; and the greatest pianistic showman in history, the Hungarian composer Franz Liszt. The field of Italian opera was dominated by Giuseppe Verdi, while German opera was virtually monopolized by Richard Wagner.

Composers like Antonin Dvorak began looking for ways in which they could express the musical soul of their homelands. Legends were therefore used as plots for operas, and folk melodies and dance rhythms were frequently used as inspiration for symphonies and instrumental music.

With the continued enhancement of instruments, plus the invention of new ones, the late Romantic composers of the second half of the nineteenth-century created richer and ever larger symphonies, ballets, and concertos. Two of the giants of this period are the German-born Johannes Brahms and the great Russian melodist Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky.
THE EARLY 20TH CENTURY ERA (1910 - 1960)

In the early part of the twentieth century music became either outwardly expressive (as in the early symphonic poems of Richard Strauss, the huge symphonies of Gustav Mahler, or the operas of Giacomo Puccini), or more introverted (as in the so-called “impressionist” music of Claude Debussy). The previous century’s tide of Nationalism found a twentieth century advocate in the Hungarian Béla Bartók.

In a time of deepening psychological awareness, the expressionistic music of Arnold Schoenberg and his disciples germinated and flourished for a time.

Twentieth-century music has seen a great coming and going of various movements, among them post-romanticism, serialism and neo-classicism in the earlier years of the century, all of which were practiced at one time or another by Russian composer Igor Stravinsky.

Many of the greatest and best-known composers of the century, including Russian composers Sergei Rachmaninov, Sergei Prokofiev, and Dmitri Shostakovich along with British composers William Walton and Benjamin Britten were those who wrote music directly descended from the approved models of the past, while investing these forms with a style and modernistic tone of their own.
THE LATE 20TH CENTURY ERA (1940 - 2000)

Composers of this era sought to free music from its rigidity, placing the performance above the composition. Similarly, many composers sought to break from traditional performance rituals by incorporating theatre and multimedia into their compositions, going beyond sound itself to achieve their artistic goals. In some cases the line is difficult to draw between genres. Composers were quick to adopt developing electronic technology. As early as the 1940s, composers such as Olivier Messiaen incorporated electronic instruments into live performance. Recording technology was used to produce art music, as well.

The musique concrète of the late 1940s and ’50s was produced by editing together natural and industrial sounds. Steve Reich created music by manipulating tape recordings of people speaking, and later went on to compose process music for traditional instruments based on such recordings. Other notable pioneers of electronic music include Edgard Varèse, Karlheinz Stockhausen, Luigi Nono, and Krzysztof Penderecki.

As more electronic technology matured, so did the music. In the 1950s aleatoric music was first championed by American composer John Cage. Early minimalist compositions of the 1960s such as those by Terry Riley, Steve Reich, and Philip Glass stemmed from aleatoric and electronic music.
THE CONTEMPORARY ERA (from 1975)

In the broadest sense, contemporary music is any music being written in the present day. In the context of classical music the term has been applied to music written in the last quarter century or so, particularly works post-1975. Minimalism was practiced heavily throughout the latter half of the century and has carried over into the 21st century, with composers like Arvo Pärt, Henryk Górecki and John Tavener working in the more popular “mystic minimalism” variant.

Recently there has been increasing stylistic variety, with far too many schools of composition to name or label. However, in general, there are three broad trends. The first is the continuation of modern avant-garde traditions, including musical experimentalism. The second are schools which sought to revitalize a tonal style based on previous common practice. The third focuses on non-functional triadic harmony, exemplified by composers working in the minimalist and related traditions.

4/18/2017

Mahler Symphony No.1 (1893 Hamburg version - Two recordings)

Challenge Classics CC72355

Please note: The downloads here are no longer active. Please go to my revised and expanded 14 March 2025 post.

01. - 05. Gustav Mahler - Symphony No.1 in D major (original Hamburg 1893 version) [56'26]

Subtitled as "Symphonic Poem in Two Parts - Titan".

Netherlands Symphony Orchestra conducted by Jan Willem de Vriend.

Challenge Classics CC72355 (recorded May 2009; first issued 2009)

(flacs and scans - digital download)


Recording venue: Muziekcentrum Enschede, Netherlands
Recording engineer and Producer: Bert van der Wolf

Although there are, of course, hundreds of recordings of Mahler's First Symphony available in its final published edition, there are very few of the first 'Hamburg' version of  1893. In fact, I only know of four - the Jan Willem de Vriend from 2009 and Wyn Morris from 1970 included here plus one on Hungaroton by Zsolt Hamar with Pannon Philharmonic, Pécs and one on Sony by Thomas Hengelbrock with NDR Symphony. I've never heard either of the latter two.

The major difference in the published version is that the Blumine second movement is discarded and orchestration is expanded and improved in the remaining four movements (particularly in the opening fanfares). The Hamburg version also has cello doubling the double-bass at the opening of the Funeral March. The subtitle is also discarded so the published version should never be referred to as 'Titan'. In my opinion, if Blumine is to be included, it should always be as part of the Hamburg version or as a completely separate stand-alone makeweight.

The performance by the Netherlands Symphony under de Vriend seems excellent as usual but unfortunately, for me the recording by Challenge Classics is not up to their usual standard even when heard in this high-resolution download. It all feels a bit gray with inner-voices smudged, not helped by the very low transfer level.

Pye Virtuoso TPLS 13037

01. - 05. Gustav Mahler - Symphony No.1 in D major (original Hamburg 1893 version) [59'10]

New Philharmonia Orchestra conducted by Wyn Morris.

Pye Virtuoso (recorded 1969 or 1970; first issued on LP in 1970)

(16bit/44.1kHz flac no scans - this rip from CD kindly provided by friend Deryk)

Recording venue: Unknown
Recording engineer:  Ray Prickett; Producer:  Isabella Wallich

This hard to find performance, originally issued on LP in 1970 was subsequently remastered for CD and issued on EMI's short-lived and punning Phoenixa label (after they acquired Pye Nixa's catalogue) and also on HMV Store's in-house label. This rip is from the HMV release; the cover of which apparently gave no indication that this was the original Hamburg version. Unfortunately, I do not have covers or booklets for either CD release so I have just included the original LP cover.

I actually quite like Morris' sensitive and powerful performance and find the recorded sound much more dynamic than de Vriend's even if it is naturally less refined.

Appendix

Everest EVC9022
01. - 04. Gustav Mahler - Symphony No.1 in D major  [46'28]

London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Adrian Boult.

Everest EVC9022 (recorded October 1958; this CD issue 1995)

(16bit/44.1kHz flac and covers - digital download)

Recorded venue: Walthamstow Assembly Hall, London
Recording engineer and Producer: Bert Whyte
Digital producer: Seymour Solomon

I still prefer the First Symphony performed in its published version and my favourite recording remains Adrian Boult's with the London Philharmonic for Everest. I have posted an earlier download before in a comment to another post on MIMIC but have included it here as this may be a better mastering. There seems to be a number of different FLAC downloads around, probably all originating from intermediate masters - all quite good but at times audibly different from each other. I really would like to get hold of a CD made from the original 35mm tapes and rip it myself.

I find this performance to be a breath of fresh air when so many other recordings offer an all very similar romantic approach. It's not only swift and exciting but also genial and exuberant. It's a great shame that Boult wasn't allowed to record more Mahler. The London Philharmonic play spectacularly well for Sir Adrian and it is difficult to believe that the splendid Everest recording is nearly 60 years old.

13 comments:

nzguy said...

Download from MEGA:
de Vriend Maher Symphony 1 (Hamburg 1893) 24/96:
https://mega.nz/#!AYgFUBSJ!zb0xlzEf7uSKvL_ifliCdnfrVddPkzJhl7X4BMES4Cw
Morris Maher Symphony 1 (Hamburg 1893):
https://mega.nz/#!lAR1EZgC!9rrt6Frokgrurh1u33d9VDoU5nuWbEEsHmPYqXCQMWU
Boult Mahler Symphony i:
https://mega.nz/#!kJZVSbBa!vV_NodghoIqNREl4_2nhfTlKx6d1gq0lOWwvg1QKiDw

AlanE49 said...

A great share! Thank you.

centuri said...

Fantastic to compare 2 versions of the rare Hamburg version.
On the hand the (very fast) interpretation under Boult is a MUST !!
Thanks so much.

nzguy said...

I have discovered one more recording of the Hamburg version - on the Norwegian Simax label with Ole Kristian Ruud conducting the Norrkoping Symphony. No great shakes, apparently.

BiggusDikkus said...

There's a Hengelbrock recording of the Hamburg version. I found it to be very good.

guiller said...

Many thanks!

norman said...

Thanks!!

meurglys0 said...

Thank you very much. I'm curious about de Vriend's recording after hearing his successful Beethoven cycle. High-rez, too!

David Federman said...

I have long searched for Wyn Morris' recording of Mahler's 1st. Thank you. He also recorded superb performances of the 4th, 8th, 9th and 10th. Well worth posting if you'd please.

Franz said...

Thank you very much for the fantastic Boult recording of Mahler 1st! I didn't knew it. I agree with you is fresh air in usually hyperromantic interpretations. Not everything works (in my modest opinion) but anyway I really appreciate it. And the quality of sound is incredible considering this should be one of the first stereo recordings.
Thanks for yourblog!
Franz

nzguy said...

@David Federman: You can find Wyn Morris' Mahler 10 here on MIMIC - http://meetinginmusic.blogspot.co.nz/2014/03/eine-kleine-mahlerfest-5-to-8.html.

I also have the 4, 8 and 9 but they come from a source which, unfortunately, doesn't allow re-posting.

nzguy said...

A lossless download of the Thomas Hengelbrock recording can be found at: https://classicalmjourney.blogspot.co.nz/2017/06/gustav-mahler-symphony-no-1-titan.html.

The booklet is here: http://i-classical.com/pdf.php?id=000044439.pdf

Phillip said...

Wonderful. Many thanks.