01 - 05 G. Mahler: Symphony No. 7 in E minor
Concertgebouw Orchestra Amsterdam
Kirill Kondrashin
Tahra TAH 451
[Recorded in Concertgebouw Amsterdam, November 1979]
[scans, individual flac files]
01 - 05 G. Mahler: Symphony No. 7 in E minor
Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester
Claudio Abbado
Musicom MC 9221
[Recorded August 1999 (place of recording not indicated)]
[scans, individual flac files]
...Mahler himself conducted the orchestra in this hall and from then on they have taken special pride in playing his music. So it’s thrilling to hear the Concertgebouw Orchestra of 1979 in this work in this hall and in an interpretation so distinguished and distinctive as this.
A good example can be heard at the start of the second movement (Nachtmusik I) where the solo horns call to each other, embroidering the air with their strange harmonies. If you are only used to studio recordings you will be used to hearing the horns close in and you might, on first hearing this recording, be a little disappointed that they sound more distant than usual. But this is how you would hear them in a concert hall and it is how Mahler himself would have expected you to hear them too. Bear that in mind when you read criticism of a conductor departing from Mahler’s score markings in a studio recording. Mahler knew nothing of "re-mixing", "spot-miking" and balance engineers. He, the conductor, was his own balance engineer and in this case the real balance engineer is Kondrashin with those credited on the record sleeve apparently there to make sure that is what we get...
Kondrashin was certainly no stranger to Mahler. His previous Mahler recordings made in Russia are quite hard to find and the orchestral playing out of the Mahler tradition. But here is a performance played by one of the great Mahler ensembles that is easy to find and should be heard by all Mahlerians and anyone convinced by the need to hear music played "live", as I am. The notes mention a recording of the First Symphony in the Dutch radio archives so let us hope Tahra can lay hands on that one too.
A superb performance of Mahler’s Seventh to be ranked with the finest but carrying an extra magic only "live" performance with realistic concert hall recording balance can bring.
Tony Duggan
The complete review of Kondrashin's performance can be found here.
DISCLAIMER: According to the Gramophone, Abbado's recording of Seventh was from Edinburgh Festival. More on that you can find here
(special thanks to person who posted Mahler's Seventh with Kondrashin on, now long "nla", web torrent site - "demonoid")
9 comments:
Concertgebouw Orchest Amsterdam, Kondrashin
https://mega.nz/file/jdkSVahR#9hUd256-5k2S5n-oR521eG8Xscou0JpRY2WurJl8Mbg
Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester, Abbado
https://mega.nz/file/iQ8VSZAQ#8-VCyKuCjS6qfkEiYm3Id8dngu5ju9BnXs0QHu9-KcU
Thanks for this Kondrashing recordings!
Thank you! While the 7th isn't among my favourites, Kondrashin usually has something interesting to convey. Look forward to listening.
Super-post, thank you Appassionato!
Thank you for these gems, Appassionato. I was familiar with the Kondrashin recording, but Abbado's is new to me. Looking forward to hearing him with an orchestra that brought out the best in him, IMHO.
Obviously one can't be certain, but there has been a recording floating around the net for some years of an Abbado/GMJO Mahler 7 given at the Edinburgh Festival on August 17 1999.
Many thanks for these Mahler recordings.
Merci infiniment pour ces versions très intéressantes!
Muchas gracias, bendiciones.
Post a Comment